Sherman M4 (Action Sixteen) Review | Amiga Power - Everygamegoing

Amiga Power

Sherman M4
By Action 16
Amiga 500

Published in Amiga Power #2

Sherman M4

Okay, so the name kind of gives the game away. It's a tank game. Of course, this being the '90s nobody would dare release a simple Battlezone clone. Nope, what we get with M4 is a complicated Battlezone clone - lots of your obligatory solid 3D vectors, a fair bit of bolt-on strategy, and a rather massive dollop of shooting. The programmers have obviously realised that tank sims are normally boring as hell, so they've plumped here for an odd sort of halfway-house between a shoot-'em-up and a strategy thang.

So how well does it work? Well, just fine for the most part, though you do get a feeling of compromise. Each time I've played it I've found myself neglecting the strategy elements after precious few minutes, and getting down to some good old-fashioned tank bashing instead. It's not that the strategy elements are badly done particularly, but they do come across as a bit of an afterthought, stuck in there to make up for the significant shortcomings in the action department.

Still, I shouldn't whinge too much. For the money it certainly offers a sizeable amount of playing time, and I do enjoy playing it in a half-hearted sort of a way, though I'd still choose Battlezone any day of the week.

The Bottom Line

Caught between two stools, M4 would have benefitted from concentrating more on a single style. An enjoyable romp nonetheless.

Mark Ramshaw

Other Amiga 500 Game Reviews By Mark Ramshaw

  • Stellar 7 Front Cover
    Stellar 7
  • Vikings: Fields Of Conquest Front Cover
    Vikings: Fields Of Conquest
  • Knightmare Front Cover
  • Pacific Islands Front Cover
    Pacific Islands
  • Hare Raising Havoc Front Cover
    Hare Raising Havoc
  • Apidya Front Cover
  • Chuck Yeagar's Advanced Flight Trainer 2.0 Front Cover
    Chuck Yeagar's Advanced Flight Trainer 2.0
  • Smash Tv Front Cover
    Smash Tv
  • The Adventures Of Willy Beamish Front Cover
    The Adventures Of Willy Beamish
  • Ugh! Front Cover